Climate cases keep landing in state court. Why it matters

In The News |

Judges across the country have now determined that climate lawsuits against oil and gas companies belong in state courts, writes Jennifer Hijazi of E&E News.


But whether climate lawsuits constitute tort claims at all has been a major point of contention in and out of the courtroom.

Oil companies should not be targeted for doing lawful business, said American Tort Reform Association President Sherman “Tiger” Joyce.

“You’re talking about energy, you’re talking about companies in an industry … that is obviously national in scope,” he said. “To say that this is interstate commerce is an understatement.”

He argued that tort expansion — like what the climate litigants propose — creates liability after the fact that is especially unfair for an industry that is already heavily regulated.

“To hold someone responsible for something — whether it’s a criminal act or whether it’s civil liability — we believe that there should be notice in advance,” he said. “You should know what the rules of the road are.”

Read more in E&E News

Latest News

View all news

Climate Case Is Ninth Circuit’s Golden Opportunity on Nuisance Suits

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has an opportunity to redirect policy and push back on activist attorneys’ attempts to improperly expand public nuisance law. With Covid-19 public nuisance lawsuits coming, Tiger Joyce, president of the American Tort Reform Association, discusses the importance of the climate change lawsuit.