Lawmakers Denounced for Pushing Punitive Damages in Last-Minute Amendment
Illinois Businesses Brace for Increased Costs and Diminished Appeal as Trial Bar Pushes for Punitive Damages in Wrongful Death Cases
Statement from the American Tort Reform Association applauding a writ of mandamus issued by the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals.
ATRA applauds the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals for its decision in In Re: CVS Pharmacy, Inc., in which it issued a writ of mandamus in an important case regarding multidistrict litigation (MDL). In the decision, issued April 15, 2020, the Court held that the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure apply to MDLs “just as it does in individual litigation.”
Writing for the Court, Judge Raymond Kethledge stated, “MDLs are not some kind of judicial border country, where the rules are few and law rarely makes an appearance.” He continued, “an MDL court’s determination of the parties’ rights in an individual case must be based on the same legal rules that apply in other cases, as applied to the record in that case alone.”
The opinion arose out of the opioid multidistrict litigation pending in federal court in Ohio. The MDL includes more than 2,700 cases filed by counties, municipalities and states across the country. The Court was asked to address three rulings by the lower court that disregarded the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. The district court allowed the counties to amend their complaint to include additional allegations against several pharmacies 19 months after the deadline and required the defendants to produce data for almost every opioid prescription filled anywhere in the United States for the past 13 years.
As a result of this decision, bellwether cases against the pharmacies over dispensing allegations may not proceed because the claims were added too late.
While multidistrict litigation is meant to increase the efficiency of the judicial system, the Court insisted “an MDL court must find efficiencies within the Civil Rules, rather than in violation of them.”
Illinois Businesses Brace for Increased Costs and Diminished Appeal as Trial Bar Pushes for Punitive Damages in Wrongful Death Cases
2023 legislative session resulted in landmark legal reforms, ATRF says
ATRA’s Latest Data Reveals $271.8 Million Spent on Legal Services Advertising in Florida in 2022; Florida Accounted for Nearly 20% of Radio Ad Spending Nationwide
Today, Johnson & Johnson announced it will resolve approximately 60,000 talc claims through the bankruptcy process, allowing claimants to get fair resolution without having to wait through a lengthy trial. […]
HB 837 heads to Governor’s desk
This letter-to-the-editor was originally published by the Tampa Bay Times in response to their March 13, 2023 article “Florida lawmakers want to help insurance companies by limiting lawsuits.“ The “tort […]